The cases below represent examples of the wide range of cases that the firm and its attorneys have handled over the years.

Civil Cases

Represented Grammy award-winning singer Enrique Iglesias in a 10 million dollar contract dispute with his former manager.

Enrique Iglesias

Successfully defended then-two-time Indianapolis 500 Champion Helio Castroneves in a big win over former racing world champion Emerson Fittipaldi when a jury denied Fittipaldi’s multi-million dollar claim that Castroneves had breached a management contract.

Helio Castroneves

Corporate Criminal Cases

The State of Florida charged this Fortune 500 Boise, Idaho-based company with criminal manslaughter after a shoplifter in their Delray Beach, Florida, supermarket accidentally died during his detention by store employees. During the course of discovery, numerous errors in the autopsy and toxicology performed were uncovered. After being presented with evidence pointing towards an incorrect opinion as to the cause of death, the State dismissed the charges prior to trial.

State of Florida v. Albertson's, Inc.

Corporate Criminal Investigations

Criminal Investigations

In June, 2011, the parents of a nine-month-old baby appeared in our office after being terrorized by police and a hospital physician, that the life-threatening injuries sustained by their baby, who fell three feet from their bed, could not have been caused by such a short distance fall and was, instead, intentional child abuse. With no evidence other than the baby’s brain injury, retinal hemorrhage and the surgeon’s opinion, the father was accused of violently shaking his baby in a manner which has become known as the Shaken Baby Syndrome.

After meeting with the parents, Mark Shapiro immediately traveled to Lee County, Florida and began an intensive investigation. The prosecutor assigned to the case was also contacted to request a meeting in advance of any charging decision being made. The prosecutor who was on the verge of filing charges and being urged by the local police to authorize the arrest of our client, agreed to “give us an hour” of her time as long as we did so within the next 14 days. In the two weeks which followed, Roy Black and Mark Shapiro reviewed and reconstructed nearly 1,000 pages of medical records and CT scans, identified and hired the finest medical experts in the country, demonstrated through the science of biomechanics that short distance falls in children could and do cause such injuries, pieced together how the baby actually fell from his parents’ bed and, ultimately, made a presentation to the prosecutor by the 14th day, as she forewarned.

After presenting the prosecutor with a comprehensive package of information, including written opinions from our experts, a biomechanical re-enactment of the fall and resulting injury, live testimony of a medical professional and a PowerPoint video detailing the nature of the injury and how it was consistent with a short distance fall, the prosecutor immediately pulled back an arrest warrant package which had already been prepared by the police in advance of our meeting. Over the next few weeks, after closely analyzing the information provided and updated science supporting our client’s innocence, the State Attorney’s Office refused to authorize the police request for an arrest warrant and declined prosecution.

Today, mom, dad and baby are doing fine.

Father of Infant Child (Shaken Baby Case)

State & Federal Trial Courts

Successfully obtained an acquittal of the only defendant to go to trial in what became known as the “Varsity Blues” Georgetown college admission scandal.  There were two defendants who went to trial and were convicted, and 54 other defendants who plead guilty.

Acquittal in "Varsity Blues" Georgetown Admission Scandal Trial

Siyuan Zhao,  a 24 year old Chinese national and exceptionally talented artist and architectural student, was charged with attempted first degree murder, after attacking another young woman while both were in attendance at the Art Basel Exhibition in Miami Beach.  Siyuan did not know her victim but attacked and stabbed her in the neck believing that the young woman was a terrorist agent for ISIS and was about to “destroy the art.”  After immediately arresting Siyuan at the scene and after  questioning by police, it was apparent that Siyuan was suffering from severe mental illness.   Attorneys Howard Srebnick and Mark Shapiro were contacted by Siyuan’s family and quickly took the necessary steps to stabilize Siyuan’s mental health condition and to defend her against the serious criminal charges. Over the next several months, leading mental health professionals were brought in and a plan was formulated to coordinate Siyuan’s mental health treatment with a legal strategy to prove that she was not legally responsible for the attack and to get her back home with her parents in Beijing.  The coordinated effort was highly successful.  Siyuan’s mental health condition was carefully managed and brought under control and, after a lengthy evidentiary hearing before a criminal court judge, Howard Srebnick and Mark Shapiro proved that Siyuan was not legally responsible for her actions.  The Court found that Siyuan was not sane at the time of the incident and permitted her to leave the United States and return home to China. Coverage in China was published in both the China Gate and the China Press.

Chinese National Art Basel Stabbing Case

A well-respected Miami plastic surgeon was charged with the attempted murder and kidnapping of his ex-girlfriend which supposedly occurred because of a Facebook posting she made.  After an exhaustive investigation that included forensic analysis of electronic devices, witness interviews, searches of police files and photographs of the alleged crime scene, a presentation was made to successfully demonstrate to prosecutors how the purported crime could not have happened.  The State declined to file felony charges, and instead filed two misdemeanor ones, to be dismissed after the client completes a deferred prosecution program.

Miami Plastic Surgeon Charged with Attempted Murder and Kidnapping 

Karlie Tomica, the self-described “Party Princess” who described herself as such on a social media website,  was 20 years old  when she struck and killed a popular Miami-Beach chef in the early morning hours as he was walking to work on Collins Avenue.  Karlie, who was driving home after finishing her overnight shift as a bartender at Nikki’s Beach Club on South Beach, had a blood alcohol level of nearly three times the legal limit, after having consumed alcoholic beverages while at work.  Though not realizing at first that she hit and killed a pedestrian, she drove away from the accident.  However, a witness to the accident began following Karlie in his car and pulled alongside of her and told her that she hit a person and to pull over.  Karlie panicked, continued to drive away and eventually drove home where police were waiting to arrest her.  Karlie was Charged with DUI Manslaughter and Leaving the Scene of an Accident involving Death. The facts of this case were particularly ugly and public sentiment, even worse.  After months of investigation and work-up of the case, and with only four days remaining before her 21st birthday, Mark Shapiro was able to negotiate a very favorable plea resolution, whereby Karlie Tomica would be sanctioned as a Youthful Offender and probation. Had she turned 21 before the deal was secured, Karlie would have been ineligible to receive the benefit of pleading as a youthful offender.

Karlie Tomica Successful Plea Negotiation 

Represented Mary Estelle Curran, an elderly widow, who was charged in one of the largest offshore bank account tax cases, for failing to pay taxes and disclose $43 million held in accounts at UBS and LGT in Switzerland.  Following a sentencing hearing before a federal judge in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida, Ms. Curran was sentenced to five seconds of federal probation.  This is perhaps the shortest term of probation ever imposed in a federal criminal case.

Elderly Widow Sentenced and Served Five Seconds of Probation

A Senior Executive Vice President of a publicly traded bank holding company and the once leading residential mortgage lender in Puerto Rico, was charged in the Southern District of New York with one count of securities fraud, four counts of wire fraud and forfeiture.  The superseding indictment returned against the client charged him with having made misrepresentations to stock analysts and investors regarding certain core characteristics of a unique and complex financial instrument known as a variable-rate interest only strip (“IO”) and the IO portfolio’s external valuation.

There was a 5-week trial where our client was convicted of certain counts and acquitted of others.  At the sentencing held on November 16, 2010, the government sought 27-34 years of imprisonment, based on their estimate of $75 million in losses and an aggregate decline in shareholder value of approximately $4 billion.   The defense established, by filing pleadings and affidavits and supported by legal argument at the sentencing, that the loss attributable to our client’s conduct could not be determined.  Our client was sentenced to 5 years.

Banker Charged with Financial Crimes Involving Derivatives in Southern District of New York

Four-time Indy race champion and Dancing with the Stars winner, Helio Castroneves, and his sister, Katia, were acquitted of 5 of 6 counts of income tax evasion after a 7-week trial.  The one charge on which the jury was deadlocked was dropped shortly thereafter.

To hear Roy Black’s closing argument in the case, click here.

To hear Howard Srebnick’s closing argument in the case, click here.

Helio Castroneves and his Sister Acquitted of Income Tax Evasion Charges

After three weeks of trial, Roy Black and Howard Srebnick left federal prosecutors stunned as a Miami jury found this South Florida Supply Corporation, its owner and sales manager not guilty on all eight counts of money laundering. The prosecution charged that the company and its employees had knowingly accepted more than $8,000,000 in drug cash as payment for gold bullion. The company is one of the largest jewelry supply companies in the country, servicing customers in the southeast United States and Latin America. Due to having a large clientele of gold customers from Colombia who paid in cash, the Internal Revenue Service and other agencies targeted the company for three years, orchestrating a taped sting operation – dubbed by the government as “Goldstar” – in which an undercover agent and confidential informant posed as customers interested in buying gold.

South Florida Jeweler Found Not Guilty on 8 Counts of Money Laundering Charges

This 40-year-old accountant was charged with Manslaughter following the highly publicized shooting death of a 16-year-old boy who was playing a late-night prank on the doorstep of the accountant’s home. The accountant maintained that he had acted in self-defense as he opened his front door and saw what he believed to be a gun in the boy’s hand. No gun was ever discovered and an eyewitness claimed that the boy was running away when the gun was fired. After a solid year of intensive investigation, forensic trace evidence analysis and interrogation of prosecution witnesses, the defense team was able to build a strong case for our client’s justifiable use of deadly force. These factors, in conjunction with four very intense days of jury selection, resulted in a particularly favorable resolution negotiated only minutes prior to the commencement of opening statements.

40-year-old Accountant Charged with Manslaughter in Shooting Death of 16-Year-Old Prankster

The defendant, a former Justice Department official, was indicted for RICO violations and accused of conspiring with his drug-lord client. The government’s motion to disqualify Howard Srebnick as trial counsel was denied.  Following a 5-month federal trial, the jury acquitted the defendant on the RICO charges and hung on the remaining counts.

Former U.S. Justice Department Official Acquitted on RICO Charges

NFL Super Bowl wide receiver was accused of laundering drug money for a childhood friend. Following a 3-week federal criminal trial, the jury returned a verdict of not guilty on all counts.

NFL Super Bowl Wide Receiver Found Not Guilty

Successful Cuban-American businesswoman indicted on 18 counts of felony customs fraud and tax evasion. After filing a motion for severance arguing that she needed the testimony of her co-defendant husband to support her innocence, the trial judge granted a dual-jury on the eve of trial and the government dropped all felony charges against her.

Felony Customs Fraud and Tax Evasion Charges Against Cuban-American Businesswoman Dropped

Six Cuban-Americans were accused of conspiring to assassinate Fidel Castro while he was delivering a speech in Venezuela. Three of the men were arrested on the high seas in possession of two .50 caliber assault rifles and high tech commando gear, and one of them supposedly confessed. Nevertheless, a Puerto Rico jury acquitted the men on all charges.

Six Cuban-Americans Charged with Conspiring to Assassinate Fidel Castro

After a 2-week-long trial, a federal jury acquitted this 35-year-old lawyer in a case where the government alleged that he knowingly engaged in graphic online sex chats with a 13-year-old girl, and drove to a Broward County park to meet her to entice her to engage in sexual activity or lewd and lascivious behavior. After arriving at the park, the LEACH task force detective who had been the one operating in an undercover capacity as the 13-year-old girl arrested the Defendant.

South Florida Attorney Charged with Knowingly Engaging in Graphic Online Sex Chats with 13-Year-Old Girl

Gary Czajkowski, owner of Chaz Equipment Company, is one of the largest underground utilities contractors in Florida. In April of 2010, Mr. Czajkowski was charged with Unlawful Compensation of a Public Official, stemming from allegations that he paid a $25,000 bribe to the Town Of Palm Beach Public Works Department construction manager.  Mr. Czajkowski’s case was seen as one of largest in Palm Beach in recent memory.

Following an intensive two-year investigation by the defense into the government’s case, Mark Shapiro and the defense team were able to prove at trial that in fact, no bribe had ever been paid and that the government’s case was based largely on speculation and the testimony of unreliable “cooperating” witnesses.  Facing up to 15 years in prison, all were relieved when the jury returned its “not guilty” verdict in just over two hours.

Owner of Large Underground Utilities Contractor Charged with Unlawful Compensation of a Public Official

State & Federal Appeal Courts

A Petition for Writ of Certiorari was granted in the case of United States v. Kaley, U.S. Supreme Court Case No. 12‐464.  The question under review is whether criminal defendants who cannot use their assets to retain counsel of choice because of an asset freeze have the constitutional right to challenge the government’s underlying charges during a pretrial hearing.

United States Supreme Court Granted Writ of Certiorari

The defendant was alleged to have been an organized crime figure. He was the subject of several months of wiretaps. After extensive hearings, the trial court suppressed all the wiretaps. The state appealed. The suppression of the wiretaps was affirmed by the Third District Court of Appeal, the Florida Supreme Court, and the United States Supreme Court. The case was subsequently dismissed.

Case Dismissed Against Alleged Organized Crime Figure

The defendant was convicted of committing a lewd and lascivious act on a child under 16. The conviction was reversed for prosecutorial misconduct.

Conviction of Lewd and Lascivious Act on a Minor Conviction Reversed